Circle Surrogacy Review What They Offer vs Surrogacy4All

By Dr. Kulsoom Baloch

Learn more about Dr. Baloch

Introduction

When choosing a surrogacy agency, it’s important to weigh your options carefully. Circle Surrogacy and Surrogacy4All are two respected agencies with different approaches, costs, and service models. This review compares them across key areas to help intended parents make an informed decision.

About CircleSurrogacy.com

Founded in 1995 and based in Boston, Circle Surrogacy is one of the longest-running surrogacy agencies in the U.S. It offers full-service programs with in-house legal support and a broad network of surrogates.

About Surrogacy4All

Founded in 2006, Surrogacy4All is a physician-owned agency based in New York, offering U.S., Canadian, and international surrogacy options. Known for fast matching and concierge- level support, it’s popular for cost-conscious intended parents.

1. Matching Time

• Circle Surrogacy: 3–9 months
• Surrogacy4All: 1–3 months (pre-screened surrogate pool)

2. Cost Comparison (2025 Estimates)

• Circle Surrogacy: $150,000 – $190,000 (U.S. only)
• Surrogacy4All: $100,000 – $135,000 (U.S.), $49,000 (international)

3. Services Offered

Both offer:

• Surrogate and donor matching
• Legal and psychological support
• Fertility clinic coordination

Only Surrogacy4All offers:

• Concierge postpartum care
• Global surrogacy (Ghana, Canada, India)
• Integrated physician oversight

4. Legal Expertise

• Circle Surrogacy: In-house legal team for contracts and court orders
• Surrogacy4All: Works with top reproductive attorneys in all 50 states and international jurisdictions

5. Diversity & Inclusivity

Both agencies are LGBTQ+ friendly and inclusive of single parents. Surrogacy4All also offers cultural matching options (e.g., Indian, Jewish surrogates) and multilingual support for international parents.

6. Reputation & Reviews

• Circle Surrogacy: Strong historical presence, but slower matching and higher cost noted in some reviews
• Surrogacy4All: High satisfaction among budget-conscious families and repeat parents

Conclusion

Circle Surrogacy is a great option if you prefer a traditional, U.S.-only agency with in- house legal handling. **Surrogacy4All** stands out for faster matching, lower fees, international flexibility, and physician-directed care—ideal for families seeking a modern, cost-effective approach.