Course / Selecting Sperm Donors
In modern fertility care, sperm donors generally fall into two categories:
Directed (or Known) Donors
– Individuals personally known to the recipient or intended parents (e.g., a friend, relative, or acquaintance).
Non-Directed (or Anonymous / Bank) Donors
– Donors recruited, screened, and distributed through regulated sperm banks or cryobanks.
Each option has distinct legal, emotional, and medical implications, and must comply with U.S. FDA and ASRM (American Society for Reproductive Medicine) guidelines.
Definition
A directed donor is an individual personally chosen by the intended parent(s), typically outside of a sperm bank setting. The donor may be a friend, colleague, or relative.
Advantages
Personal Connection: Allows recipients to know the donor’s background, personality, and traits firsthand.
Genetic Familiarity: In cases such as within same-sex couples or known familial donation, some genetic continuity may be desired.
Transparency: No mystery about medical or family history beyond testing.
Key Medical & Legal Considerations
FDA and Screening Requirements:
Even for directed donors, U.S. law mandates infectious disease testing (HIV, hepatitis B/C, syphilis, etc.) and semen analysis. Most clinics require a 6-month quarantine and retesting before use.
Legal Agreements:
Written, notarized consent forms and legal contracts must clarify parental rights and responsibilities, explicitly confirming that the donor relinquishes parental claims.
The agreement should be prepared by an ART-specialized attorney to comply with state surrogacy and family law statutes.
Ethical & Emotional Counseling:
Psychological counseling for both donor and intended parents is recommended to prevent future conflicts or emotional complications.
Medical Follow-up:
Donor’s long-term health and potential genetic findings should be tracked if possible, for the child’s benefit.
Clinic Best Practices
At Surrogacy4All, we recommend:
Independent legal counsel for all parties
Full FDA-compliant screening
A psychological evaluation before proceeding
Clear clinic consent forms outlining roles and expectations
Definition
A sperm bank donor (also called a non-directed donor) is an individual who donates sperm through a licensed facility, with strict medical and genetic screening before the samples are released for use.
Advantages
Comprehensive Medical & Genetic Screening:
Donors undergo multi-level testing for infectious and hereditary conditions.
Quarantined Samples:
All sperm is cryopreserved and held for a minimum of 6 months, ensuring accurate retesting before release.
Legal Clarity:
Donors sign binding agreements waiving parental rights, offering strong legal protection for intended parents.
Wide Selection:
Donors are cataloged by phenotype, ethnicity, education, interests, and genetic traits, allowing precise matching.
Privacy & Confidentiality:
The donor and intended parents typically do not meet, preserving privacy for both sides.
Surrogacy Context
For intended parents using gestational carriers, sperm bank donors are typically preferred due to regulatory compliance, traceability, and simplicity of consent documentation. Most U.S. surrogacy programs—including Surrogacy4All—advise this route for risk minimization.
Definition
An open-identity or identity-release donor agrees to allow potential contact with offspring once the child reaches adulthood (usually age 18), under regulated circumstances managed by the sperm bank.
Key Features
Future Connection Option:
Donor-conceived children may access identifying information in adulthood, supporting transparency and personal identity development.
Ethical Transparency:
Increasingly recommended by fertility societies as the preferred model for donor-conceived children’s rights.
Maintains Parental Legal Boundaries:
Despite future contact, open-identity donors have no parental rights or obligations.
Best For
Families who value openness and wish to give their future child access to biological information
Parents who appreciate long-term traceability without compromising current privacy or legal protection
Surrogacy4All Practice Note
We generally recommend open-identity donors for clients prioritizing child welfare and ethical transparency. Our affiliated sperm banks provide a variety of such donors, screened and registered with identity-release protocols.
Definition
A nonidentified or anonymous donor has no personal contact or identity disclosure to the recipient or child. All interactions are mediated by the sperm bank.
Advantages
Complete Privacy:
Neither the donor nor recipient knows the other’s identity.
Simplicity:
Quick process with established legal contracts through the bank.
Availability:
Wider pool of donors, often at lower cost than open-identity programs.
Limitations
Restricted Access to Donor Information:
The child cannot later access identifying details.
Changing Norms:
With advances in consumer DNA testing (e.g., 23andMe, AncestryDNA), absolute anonymity can no longer be guaranteed.
Ethical Concerns:
Some child-advocacy and psychological organizations encourage more transparent donor policies for future offspring identity rights.
Professional Recommendation
Anonymous donation remains legally sound but may not align with evolving societal expectations around genetic identity. At Surrogacy4All, we guide families through both options, ensuring their choice fits personal, cultural, and ethical preferences.
Our job is to listen, to connect the dots between your needs, and to determine how we can best help you have your baby. If you’re asking how much does it cost for a surrogate, we’ll walk you through every step of the process to ensure there are no surprises.
To make an appointment with one of our counselors or physicians, please call (212) 661-7673 or email info@surrogacy4all.com. We look forward to hearing from you.
Surrogacy4All is a unique international surrogacy service targeted at providing state of the art IVF and surrogacy services to Intended Parents irrespective of age, sex or color, at the lowest possible cost in the world.
Secret Guide to Minimizing Surrogacy Costs
All Rights Reserved to Surrogacy4all