Course / Conventional Insemination or ICSI
The fundamental goal of both Conventional Insemination and ICSI is the same: to create a viable embryo. However, the methodology and level of intervention are vastly different.
Conventional Insemination: The Natural Selection Model
Conventional insemination mimics natural selection at a microscopic level. In this process:
Preparation:Â Both eggs and sperm are prepared. Mature eggs are placed in a culture dish. A sperm sample is “washed” and concentrated to select the most motile sperm.
Insemination:Â Approximately 50,000 to 100,000 motile sperm are placed into the dish with each mature egg.
Fertilization:Â The sperm compete to penetrate the egg’s outer layer (the zona pellucida). The first successful sperm triggers a biochemical reaction that prevents any other sperm from entering, leading to fertilization.
In essence, the sperm’s inherent ability to swim, penetrate, and fertilize is the key to success.
ICSI: The Precision Intervention Model
ICSI (Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection) is a micromanipulation procedure that bypasses almost all the natural steps of fertilization. It was developed in 1992 to overcome severe male factor infertility. The process is as follows:
Immobilization:Â A single sperm is selected and immobilized using a fine glass needle.
Injection:Â A single mature egg is held steady with a specialized holding pipette.
Fertilization:Â The sharp injection pipette is used to pierce the egg’s outer layers and inject the single sperm directly into the cytoplasm (the inner material) of the egg.
ICSI guarantees that a sperm reaches the inside of the egg, but it does not guarantee fertilization, as that depends on the subsequent biological compatibility of the egg and sperm.
Choosing the right fertilization method is a critical clinical decision. The following guidelines illustrate which patients are best suited for each technique.
When Conventional Insemination is the Recommended Standard
Conventional insemination is the appropriate and effective first-line treatment for couples without male factor infertility. This includes situations with:
Unexplained Infertility:Â When all standard tests (semen analysis, ovulation, tubes, etc.) are normal.
Tubal Factor Infertility:Â When the female partner has blocked or damaged fallopian tubes.
Ovulatory Disorders:Â Such as PCOS (Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome).
Fertility Preservation:Â For egg freezing, where the future sperm sample is unknown, conventional insemination is typically the default plan unless a male factor is later identified.
Donor Sperm Cycles:Â When using sperm from a proven, fertile donor.
In these scenarios, conventional insemination allows for natural selection to occur and is a less invasive and less expensive laboratory procedure.
When ICSI is a Medically Necessary Intervention
ICSI is a revolutionary tool that is medically indicated for specific diagnoses, primarily involving sperm-related issues:
Severe Male Factor Infertility:Â This is the primary indication for ICSI. It includes:
Very low sperm count (severe oligospermia).
Poor sperm motility (asthenospermia).
Abnormal sperm morphology (teratospermia).
The complete absence of sperm in the ejaculate (azoospermia), requiring surgical sperm retrieval from the testicles (TESE/TESA) or epididymis (PESA). ICSI is mandatory when using surgically retrieved sperm, as these sperm are often immotile or immature.
Previous IVF Failure:Â A history of failed fertilization or very low fertilization rates (<30%) with conventional insemination in a prior IVF cycle strongly suggests the need for ICSI in a subsequent cycle.
Preimplantation Genetic Testing (PGT):Â When embryos are being biopsied for PGT, ICSI is used to ensure that no extra sperm cells are attached to the outside of the embryo, which could contaminate the genetic sample.
Fertilization of Previously Frozen Eggs (Oocyte Thaw):Â While not always mandatory, many clinics prefer ICSI for thawed eggs because the freezing process can sometimes harden the egg’s outer shell (zona pellucida), making it more difficult for sperm to penetrate.
Despite its clear medical indications, the use of ICSI has expanded dramatically and is often employed in cases where it does not offer a proven benefit. This “ICSI Creep” is driven by several factors:
Fear of Total Fertilization Failure (TFF):Â The most significant driver is the clinician’s and patient’s fear that no eggs will fertilize. For many, the additional cost of ICSI is seen as “insurance” against this devastating outcome, even when the risk is low.
Optimizing Fertilization Rates:Â Some clinics use ICSI to achieve a more predictable and consistent fertilization rate across all mature eggs, moving away from the variable outcomes of conventional insemination.
Non-Medical Factors:Â In cycles involving surrogacy or egg donation, where the financial and emotional stakes are exceptionally high, there is a tendency to “throw everything at it,” including ICSI, even without a male factor diagnosis.
Clinic Protocol and Economics:Â In some clinics, ICSI has become the default protocol for all IVF cycles, simplifying lab workflow. It is also a more expensive procedure, which can contribute to its overuse.
The Expert Takeaway: For patients with normal semen parameters, multiple high-quality studies and meta-analyses have concluded that ICSI does not improve live birth rates compared to conventional insemination. It is an unnecessary expense and intervention when the sperm are capable of fertilizing the egg on their own.
While ICSI is a safe and well-established technique, it is a more invasive procedure than conventional insemination and is not without theoretical risks and considerations.
Bypassing Natural Selection:Â The primary theoretical concern is that ICSI allows sperm that would never have been able to fertilize an egg naturally to still create an embryo. There is a concern that this could inadvertently pass on genetic issues.
Potential for Genetic Risks:
Male Infertility Link:Â Men with severe male factor infertility, particularly those with very low sperm counts (azoospermia), have a higher incidence of genetic abnormalities, such as Y-chromosome microdeletions or cystic fibrosis gene mutations. ICSI can transmit these genetic causes of infertility to male offspring.
Slight Increase in Sex Chromosome Abnormalities:Â Some studies indicate a very slight increase (less than 1%) in sex chromosome abnormalities in babies born from ICSI. It is unclear if this is due to the procedure itself or the underlying infertility of the parents.
Technical and Biological Risks:
Egg Damage:Â The physical act of injecting the egg carries a 1-3% risk of damaging the egg, rendering it non-viable.
Failed Fertilization:Â Even with a sperm directly inside the egg, fertilization may not occur if the egg’s activation mechanism is not triggered.
Our job is to listen, to connect the dots between your needs, and to determine how we can best help you have your baby. If you’re asking how much does it cost for a surrogate, we’ll walk you through every step of the process to ensure there are no surprises.
To make an appointment with one of our counselors or physicians, please call (212) 661-7673 or email info@surrogacy4all.com. We look forward to hearing from you.
Surrogacy4All is a unique international surrogacy service targeted at providing state of the art IVF and surrogacy services to Intended Parents irrespective of age, sex or color, at the lowest possible cost in the world.
Secret Guide to Minimizing Surrogacy Costs
All Rights Reserved to Surrogacy4all